CITY OF
COMMISSION MEETING
TUESDAY, JULY 17,
2007
WORKSHOP – 5:30
P.M.
REGULAR MEETING –
7:00 P.M.
MINUTES
WORKSHOP MINUTES:
Mayor Jack Brady called the workshop
to order at 5:30 p.m. in Chambers “B” at
ROLL CALL:
Mayor Jack Brady
Vice Mayor Rich Moyle
Commissioner Gary
Frankel
Commissioner John
Cangemi
Commissioner David
Hilton
City Manager Richard
Sala
City Attorney Michael
Cirullo
Deputy Clerk Patricia
Vancheri
SUBJECT: Proposed Comprehensive Pay
and Classification Plan 2007/2008
City Manager Richard Sala and Finance Director Brian Raducci presented a Power-Point presentation of the Proposed Comprehensive Pay and Classification Plan for the Fiscal Year 2007/2008. The presentation outlined the highlights of the plan.
Mr. Sala started off the meeting by thanking the staff for their work in preparing the changes and said that the most significant thing is that they are preventing layoffs and are filling some positions with qualified people.
Mr. Raducci pointed out some of the important budget dates. He provided a budget overview. Mr. Sala said that there are two parts to the Property Tax Reform Plan. One part of the plan deals with the budget process and the request of the State for the City to roll back the millage rate to the FY 2007 level. The second part of the plan, depending on the level of growth in the City, may result in a penalty being imposed. This second part of the plan could be affected by the results of a January vote. Mr. Sala went on to outline the impact of adopting a higher rate, or lowering it in September if something comes up.
Mr. Raducci pointed out the profit and losses for the Fire Rescue Assessment and the challenges for 2008, which includes increased police costs; crossing guard control; health insurance; property insurance; neighborhood and home repair funding; capital projects; new vehicle funding; salary adjustments; and debt service for the school facility.
Mr. Sala outlined some cost saving measures which would relate to some of the departments such as Parks and Recreation; Public Works and Community Development.
One suggestion was to eliminate
the holiday parade in favor of keeping North Lauderdale Days as the main City
event. Another was to eliminate some of
the activities at
Mr. Sala said a cost saving measure in the Fire Dept. would be to reduce the overtime from 48 hour week to a 53 hour on duty work week. Also, he recommends delaying the purchase of a new fire truck and freezing three firefighter/paramedic positions. A recommendation was made to eliminate the Boys and Girls Club maintenance contribution, but it was agreed to adjust the budget to include full funding. Mr. Sala indicated that the City Clerk’s expenses have been reduced by 50% based on the new salary/benefits range for the open City Clerk position. After discussion about the City Newsletter, it was decided that the circulation would be cut from four times a year to three times a year. Two additional cost saving measures was to eliminate the holiday gift card to employees and reducing the budget of the Multi-Cultural Committee.
Mr. Brian Raducci went on to outline some of the new revenues which would be beneficial to the budget. He suggested raising the shelter fees in the Parks and Recreation Department. After discussion, it was agreed that the fees would increase to $60.00 for a small shelter and $85.00 for a large shelter. It was also agreed that the Public Works Department would increase the storm water fees from $3.00 to $6.00. The Community Development Department will institute a fast tracking permit fee and also charge for all pre-plan and plan review permits.
In the City Clerk’s office the lien search fees will be increased from $30.00 to $40.00 to offset the costs of the service and also, non-business related notary public services will be $3.00 for the execution fee.
The City Manager mentioned ways that the Human Resources Department could recover costs. He recommended getting reimbursement from employees for physicals, and also for any certification or training costs incurred by the City, if the employee leaves their position before their first year is up.
With regard to the Fire Dept., Mr. Sala and Mr. Raducci recommended getting 100% recovery of assessable costs, by increasing transport fees and improving collection of transport bills by using a collection agency. He also recommended increasing the fees and fines for alarm registration and false alarm reports.
In summary, the recommendations outlined by Mr. Sala and Mr. Raducci were to maintain the millage rate; increase fire/rescue assessment; maintain the North Lauderdale Water Control District fund; adopt the recommendations with the amendments discussed.
There being no further discussions, the meeting adjourned at 6:50 p.m.
COMMISSION MEETING MINUTES:
Mayor Brady called the meeting to order at 7:13 p.m.
1. INVOCATION AND PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE –
Commissioner Cangemi gave the invocation.
2. ROLL CALL: All present
Mayor Jack
Brady
Vice Mayor Rich Moyle
Commissioner John Cangemi
Commissioner David Hilton
City Manager Richard Sala
City Attorney Michael Cirullo
Deputy Clerk Patricia Vancheri
3.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES:
a.
Workshop and Regular Meeting - June 19, 2007
Commissioner Frankel moved to approve the
minutes as submitted. Seconded by
Commissioner Cangemi. All in favor.
MINUTES APPROVED UNANIMOUSLY.
4.
PRESENTATIONS
a.
Chief Kevin Bowman – Executive Fire Officer
Program Certificate –
Chief Lou Cavallo commended Chief Kevin Bowman on his completion of the
four year program to obtain this certification from the U.S. Department of
Homeland Security and the U.S. Fire Administration’s
b. Division
Chief - Rudy Neumann – Chief Fire Officer Award – (Presented by Chief Bowman)
Chief Bowman commended Division Chief Rudy Neumann on his highly
impressive accomplishment for his designation as a Chief Fire Officer through
the Center for Public Safety Excellence.
He said the CPSE awards this designation to an individual who has demonstrated
his skills and abilities required for the fire and
5. PUBLIC DISCUSSION - None
6.
QUASI-JUDICIAL ITEMS
SPECIAL EXCEPTION USE SEU 07-04
NAME OF APPLICANT: Home Depot
PROJECT NAME: MMJ Hot
Dogs Inc.
PROJECT LOCATION:
PROJECT DESCRIPTION: Special Exception Use permit request to
operate a Permanent Outdoor Vendor operation (MMJ Hot Dogs, Inc.) within a
General Business (B-3) Zoning District.
City Attorney Mike Cirullo swore in all interested parties.
Tammy Reed-Holguin gave a staff presentation and indicated that the item
was a motion to approve the Special Exception Use permit to allow a
Permanent Outdoor Vendor (MMJ Hot Dogs, Inc.) at the
Public Hearing opened. No comments. Public Hearing closed. No commission discussion. Commissioner Frankel made a motion to approve. Seconded by Commissioner Hilton. All in favor.
MOTION APPROVED UNANIMOUSLY.
7.
BUDGET RELATED ITEMS
a.
RESOLUTION: Adoption of a Tentative Millage Rate for the
General Operating Budget and Debt Service For Fiscal Year 2007/2008
Commissioner Frankel made a motion to read the item. Commissioner Hilton seconded the motion. All in favor.
Attorney read:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, ADOPTING A TENTATIVE MILLAGE RATE OF 6.4292 MILS FOR GENERAL OPERATING BUDGET PURPOSES AND A TENTATIVE MILLAGE RATE OF .2430 MILS FOR DEBT SERVICE FOR A TOTAL COMBINED MILLAGE RATE OF 6.6722 MILS FOR FISCAL YEAR 2007/2008 PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF AND SETTING FORTH THE DATE, TIME AND PLACE OF THE FIRST PUBLIC HEARING TO FORMALLY ADOPT THE FISCAL YEAR 2007/2008 MILLAGE RATE; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Staff presentation was made in the workshop. Commissioner Frankel moved to approve. Seconded by Commissioner Cangemi. No Commission discussion. All in favor.
RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5242 ADOPTED UNANIMOUSLY
b.
RESOLUTION:
Comprehensive Pay Plan 2007/2008
Commissioner Hilton made a motion to read. Seconded by Commissioner Cangemi. All in favor.Attorney read:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, REPEALING RESOLUTION 06-07-5027 WHICH RESOLUTION DID ADOPT THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE COMPREHENSIVE PAY AND CLASSIFICATION PLAN FOR FISCAL YEAR 2006/2007, AND AS AMENDED FROM TIME TO TIME, AND HEREBY ESTABLISHING A REVISED PAY AND CLASSIFICATION PLAN FOR FISCAL YEAR 2007/08 COMMENCING ON OCTOBER 1, 2007; PROVIDING FOR THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A NEW CLASSIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; AND, PROVIDING AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Mr. Sala said they touched on some of the positions and changes in the
budget in the workshop and now would like the Human Resource department, and
other department heads, to share some of the efficiencies and recommendations
of the comprehensive pay plan.
Mr.
Mr. King also mentioned the outsourcing of the Utility Billing Department,
but said no-one would lose a position as their positions will be absorbed by
U.S. Water. He also outlined four Public
Works position changes which include two meter readers and two customer service
representatives, however, these positions will be absorbed by vacant
positions. Mr. King also recommended outsourcing
the city garage to Penske, who has agreed to hire the city’s current employees
so their positions remain intact. Mr.
King advised the Commission that if they agree to these changes they will save
the City approximately $300,000.00 annually.
Mr. King also recommends reclassifying three positions. One would reclassify the Executive City Clerk
position to a City Clerk Aide, possibly changing that title to City Clerk
Specialist. He said they would also like
to reclassify the Code Administrative Assistant to Community Development
Specialist and would like to create a lead Code Officer position to function as
foreman. Mr. King also would like to
create two positions, based on recommendations from the Commission. One position would be a part-time Code
Officer who would hit hot target areas and the other would be to allow there to
be an officer for each district. Mr.
Sala said the goal here is to try to get more compliance in each district. He said the Code Department has been
reorganizing and upon approval, this would allow the department to be more
aggressive in improving accountability from the public. Mr. Sala said the funds for this change have
already been allocated by the reorganization of this department and remain the
same.
Another highlight of the plan indicated by Mr. King was the
recommendation of 3% salary adjustment for 2007/08 for FPE, MBPFF and general
employees for a cost of living increase.
He said the basic rate for
Mr. King then asked for approval of the recommendations for the
Comprehensive Pay Plan and asked the Commission if there were any questions.
Mr. Frankel commended Mr. King on a good job preparing the plan in
fairness, savings and tweaking. He said
only one thing he wanted to mention was not to reclassify the City Clerk’s
department. He mentioned that in the
workshop they agreed to cut the number of times to release a newsletter to save
costs. In that light he suggested
reorganizing the Public Information dept. together with the City Clerk
department. Mr. Frankel distributed a former charter which highlighted that the
City Clerk’s office was responsible for the public information. He suggested saving one position by combining
those departments. Mr. Cirullo said there
were other issues to look at with regard to contracts, and that the charter
provides that the City Clerk hires a deputy.
Mr. Cirullo said the City Clerk’s position is vacant and the
recommendation would be to leave the Clerk’s department as is until such time
as a Clerk is hired. Mr. Moyle said we
need a City Clerk, and it is a real reach to say that because Public
Information department used to be a City Clerk function in previous years, they
should change it again, since that position was created by the former City
Manager. Mr. Moyle said the Public
Information Department does a good job but sees no qualifications to be put in
the City Clerk’s office. After
discussion, the Commission agreed to actively seek a City Clerk and leave the
Public Information department as is. Vice-Mayor
Moyle made a motion to approve the pay plan as recommended by
administration. Commissioner Cangemi
seconded. The motion was approved on a
four to one vote, with Mayor Brady dissenting.
RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5243 PASSED AND ADOPTED (4-1 VOTE)
8. CONSENT AGENDA
Commissioner Hilton moved to pull item 8 c. from the consent agenda and Mayor Brady pulled item 8 b. as well. Commissioner Hilton made a motion to pull 8 b. and 8 c. from the consent agenda and to read the remainder. Commissioner Cangemi seconded the motion. All in favor.
Attorney read:
a. RESOLUTION - Coconut Creek High School Contract to use Jerry Resnick Aquatic Center
A RESOLUTION OF THE
CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
RESOLUTION NO.
07-07-5244 PASSED AND ADOPTED UNANIMOUSLY
ITEMS REMOVED FROM CONSENT AGENDA: b.
Commissioner Frankel moved to read. Seconded by Commissioner Cangemi. All yes. Attorney read: A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF
Mayor Brady wanted to know who made a bid. Mr. Sala said one of the units was hit by lightning and damaged. He said they are comparing three bids. Mr. Moyle wanted to know if the insurance covers it. Mr. King answered that it must be a named storm. Mr. Sala said they are looking into means of reimbursement, but it must be fixed since we are currently marketing the building. Commissioner Hilton made a motion to approve. Seconded by John Cangemi. All yes. RESOLUTION NO.
07-07-5245 PASSED AND ADOPTED UNANIMOUSLY c.
ORDINANCE- First Procedures Revisions Commissioner Hilton moved to read. Seconded by Commissioner Frankel. All yes. Attorney read: AN
ORDINANCE OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, AMENDING CHAPTER 70 OF
THE NORTH LAUDERDALE CODE OF ORDINANCES, ENTITLED “UTILITIES”; AMENDING
SECTION 70-4, ENTITLED “SIMULTANEOUS WATER, SEWER AND STORMWATER MANAGEMENT
RATES”; AMENDING SECTION 70-6, ENTITLED “BILLING PROCEDURE, DELINQUENT
ACCOUNTS”, BY REVISING THE TIMEPERIOD AND FINE AMOUNTS FOR DELINQUENT
ACCOUNTS; AMENDING SECTION 60 OF APPENDIX F, ENTITLED “WATER AND SEWER –
GENERALLY”, BY SPECIFICALLY REVISING THE FINE AMOUNTS FOR THE DISCONTINUANCE
OF WATER SERVICE FOR NONPAYMENTS OF AMOUNTS BILLED; PROVIDING FOR
CODIFICATION; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING
AN EFFECTIVE DATE. Mr.
Sala brought up the slide as shown in the workshop and reiterated that they
are trying to get compliance and cover the cost for the services. Commissioner Cangemi suggested that the
cost for tampering and damaging broken straps should be increased. Vice-Mayor Moyle agreed that the charge
should be increased for attempts to steal water to $80.00. Commissioner Frankel thinks the after hours
fee should be reduced. Vice-Mayor
Moyle suggested $50.00. Vice-Mayor
Moyle suggested re-couping costs for doing bench-tests. It was also discussed to change the deposit
amount to compare to the average of three months utility charges. Mr. Raducci
will look into that. Mr. Sala said
the second reading will reflect the changes. Commissioner
Hilton made a motion to approve the Ordinance, first reading, as
amended. Seconded by Commissioner
Frankel. All yes. ORDINANCE ADOPTED
ON FIRST |
d. Computer Replacements/Surplus for FY 2007
(i.)
RESOLUTION:
Purchase of replacement computers
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE CITY
MANAGER TO TAKE ALL STEPS NECESSARY TO MAKE AN EXPENDITURE OF $25,200 FOR THE
PURCHASE OF REPLACEMENT COMPUTERS AS SET FORTH IN SECTION 1 BELOW, MADE A
SPECIFIC PART OF THIS RESOLUTION FROM DELL COMPUTERS; PROVIDING FOR FUNDING;
AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE
RESOLUTION NO.
07-07-5246 PASSED AND ADOPTED
UNANIMOUSLY
(ii.) RESOLUTION: Declaring certain computers as surplus
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION
OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA DECLARING THOSE CERTAIN COMPUTERS AS
LISTED IN SECTION 1 BELOW, AS SURPLUS TO THE NEEDS OF THE CITY OF NORTH
LAUDERDALE, DUE TO THE CONDITION OF THE EQUIPMENT OR PROPERTY AND/OR THE
CURRENT NEEDS OF THE CITY; AND PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5247 PASSED AND ADOPTED UNANIMOUSLY
Commissioner Hilton made a motion to approve the Consent Agenda as read. Seconded by Vice Mayor Moyle. All in favor.
9.
OTHER BUSINESS
a.
Commissioner Frankel moved to read. Commissioner Hilton seconded. All yes.
Attorney read:
(i.)
RESOLUTION: Jack Brady Sports Complex
A RESOLUTION OF THE
CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING AND
DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER, OR HIS DESIGNEE, TO TAKE ALL STEPS NECESSARY TO
SUBMIT AN APPLICATION FOR FUNDING UNDER THE FLORIDA RECREATION DEVELOPMENT
ASSISTANCE PROGRAM FOR THE RENOVATIONS AT THE JACK BRADY SPORTS COMPLEX;
PROVIDING FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS WITH REGARD TO THE BENEFITS TO BE
DERIVED BY ACCEPTING SUCH GRANT FUNDS; PROVIDING
FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
Michael Sargis presented the item. He indicated that a public hearing is required for a FDRP grant. He said they are looking to apply for two grants during the month of September. The first has to do with the Jack Brady Sports Complex. He further stated that the complex has not been renovated since the 1980’s and there are some things that are in need. Mr. Sargis said that the grant is a $400,000 grant; $200,000 would come from the State and a 50% match would be required from the City, which would be $200,000. He said the money is a part of the capital budget that the Commission approved in the first reading of the budget. If the grants are not approved and awarded, the money goes back into the city reserve. He said the money would be used to renovate the most important things first such as restrooms, fencing, sod, parking and play areas and then adding amenities as they fit the budget.
Public hearing opened. No public discussion. Public hearing closed. Commissioner Frankel moved to approve. Commissioner Hilton seconded. No Commission discussion. All in favor.
RESOLUTION NO.
07-07-5248 PASSED AND ADOPTED
UNANIMOUSLY
(ii.)
RESOLUTION:
Commissioner Hilton moved to
read. Commissioner Frankel
seconded. All yes.
Attorney read:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER, OR HIS DESIGNEE, TO TAKE ALL STEPS NECESSARY TO SUBMIT AN APPLICATION FOR FUNDING UNDER THE FLORIDA RECREATION DEVELOPMENT ASSISTANCE PROGRAM FOR RENOVATIONS AT THE HAMPTONS PINES PARK; PROVIDING FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS WITH REGARD TO THE BENEFITS TO BE DERIVED BY ACCEPTING SUCH GRANT FUNDS; PROVIDING FOR CONFLICTS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5249
Mr. Sargis presented the
item. He showed an aerial photo of
THE FOLLOWING ITEM WAS WALKED ON TO THE AGENDA:
Commissioner Hilton made a motion to read. Seconded by Commissioner Cangemi. All in favor.
Attorney read:
A RESOLUTION OF THE CITY COMMISSION OF THE CITY OF NORTH LAUDERDALE, FLORIDA, AUTHORIZING AND DIRECTING THE CITY MANAGER, OR HIS DESIGNEE, TO TAKE ALL STEPS NECESSARY TO SUBMIT AN APPLICATION FOR FUNDING UNDER THE BROWARD COUNTY CDBG DISASTER RECOVERY GRANT FOR RENOVATIONS TO THE WEST END OF HAMPTON PINES PARK; PROVIDING FOR FINDINGS AND CONCLUSIONS WITH REGARD TO THE BENEFITS TO BE DERIVED BY ACCEPTING SUCH GRANT FUNDS; PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR AN EFFECTIVE DATE.
RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5250
Public hearing opened for both resolutions. No public discussion. Public hearing closed. No Commission discussions.
Commissioner Hilton made a motion to approve both the grant applications, with the understanding that if the CDBG grant is received, the FRDP grant will be rescinded. Commissioner Cangemi seconded the motion. All yes.
RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5249 AND RESOLUTION NO. 07-07-5250 PASSED AND ADOPTED UNANIMOUSLY
10.
REPORTS
a. Vending
Machine Bid - Michael Sargis
indicated that they will be sending out bids for non-drink snack machines and
will come back and make a recommendation at the end of the bidding session.
b.
Purchase of
Water Splash Area Components – Michael Sargis gave an update on the purchase
of the authorized items for the water splash area and said they have started,
through the engineer’s office, to contact about five or six leading vendors to
obtain RFP quotes and believes that the purchase will be well under the
budgeted amount for this project. He
said he will be bringing the purchases back to the Commission for ratification
in September.
c.
Milli
Dyer Public Safety Bldg. - Fire Station 34 Construction Update –
Bill Peck gave an update and said the first
floor slab has been poured and the first floor walls have been done. He said March of 2008 is the targeted date
for completion. He said the city is doing some utility work and the City has an
interlocal agreement with the County for reimbursement of some of the funds
expended to do the job. They have gotten
firm prices from the contractor for the project. Mr. Sala said okay to move forward.
11.
COMMISSION COMMENTS
Mayor Brady said he would like to obtain requests for proposal bids on
hurricane debris each year. He said we had two companies last year but should
go ahead and get bids. Mr. Sala
elaborated and said this may take some time, but in the meantime, the
Commission doesn’t meet again until September. So in the event of a hurricane issue, if the
Mayor had to declare a state of emergency, then in that case they would have to
revert back to what was approved a few months ago. After discussion about the RFP criteria and
the process, it was agreed to have the City Attorney draft the documents and
perhaps have a special meeting to approve it.
Mayor Brady made a motion to obtain Request for Proposal on hurricane
debris removal. He also indicated that
it would be up to the Commission to rank and choose the vendor. Seconded by
Vice-Mayor Moyle. All in favor.
MOTION APPROVED UNANIMOUSLY.
Mayor Brady went on to mention that he would like to see something
rejuvenated which was previously available, which is a “vial of life”
refrigerator magnet, which listed medical information in it for families in
case of emergencies. He said he spoke to
Chief Cavallo about it and he will look into it.
Commissioner Cangemi spoke about a meeting with Wal-Mart and the City
Manager. He said he was not happy with
the selections made for the types of restaurants proposed for the project. City Manager Sala received something late
today from Wal-Mart and will pass on the information to Commission for review
and comments.
Vice-Mayor Moyle asked about chemicals in the canals. Mr. Peck said they did not put in chemicals
while the canals were low, but will resume when canal levels are back.
Commissioner Hilton said it has been two years since the lights were
installed on
12.
CITY MANAGER COMMENTS
Mr. Sala thanked the Assistant City Manager and the Department Heads for
working so hard on the budget and pay plan and he is happy that they were able
to make ends meet and produce the level of services that the City is used
to. Mr. Sala also announced that the
finance director, Brian Raducci, has accepted a job with the City of
13.
CITY ATTORNEY COMMENTS
a.
Update:
Property Tax Reform Lawsuit
Mr. Cirullo said there is a lawsuit still pending and just found out
about the joinder of the firefighters in it.
He said the lawsuit was shot back from the Supreme Court down to the
lower court. He said none of the merits
have been passed but it has been sent to a trial court judge for hearing. Mr. Cirullo said to his knowledge, no cities,
counties or leagues have joined it. He
will confirm about the firefighters and will continue to update.
14. ADJOURNMENT: Meeting adjourned at 9:00 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Patricia Vancheri
Deputy City Clerk